Choosing a company car or car allowance depends on the car, its list price and emissions, your business mileage and your tax rate. A new electric company car is often tax-efficient because its 2026/27 benefit rate is 4%. For a higher-emission petrol or diesel, a car allowance or your own car with approved mileage can cost less.
You need to compare both sides: Your personal tax and the company's Corporation Tax and National Insurance. A low monthly lease payment does not tell you the full cost.
★★★★★"I've been with Clearcrest since 2023, and whenever I've got a question, whether it's how to pay myself, a car lease, or a deal I'm looking at, I get a clear answer, usually the same day. It's like having a finance team on call."
Jack, Jaxxons Group
We broke down the tax impact of leasing a company car for Jack, who runs property sourcing consultancy Jaxxons Group. Read Jack's Jaxxons Group case study
How is a director car allowance taxed?
A director car allowance is normally additional salary. It goes through PAYE, with Income Tax at your marginal rate, employee National Insurance and employer National Insurance. The allowance is not a tax-free motoring budget.
For a director already above the £50,270 upper earnings limit in 2026/27, employee National Insurance is 2%. Employer National Insurance is generally 15% above the secondary threshold. Both the allowance and deductible employer National Insurance can normally reduce the company's taxable profit.
You then pay for the car personally. For eligible business travel in your own car, the company can pay approved mileage allowance payments tax-free up to 55p a mile for the first 10,000 business miles in 2026/27, then 25p. From 06/04/2027, the rate above 10,000 miles is due to rise to 35p. Payments above the approved amount need reporting; ordinary commuting is not business travel.
What is the benefit in kind on a company car?
Where a company car is available for private use, including commuting, the taxable benefit is normally the car's P11D list price multiplied by the appropriate percentage. Emissions, and for some hybrids electric range, set that percentage. Availability for only part of a year and employee capital contributions can reduce it.
The director pays Income Tax on the benefit. The company pays Class 1A National Insurance at 15% in 2026/27. Employer-provided fuel for private journeys is a separate benefit.
| Illustrative car, available all year | P11D list price | 2026/27 rate | Taxable benefit | Director tax at 40% | Class 1A NI at 15% |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Zero-emission | £40,000 | 4% | £1,600 | £640 | £240 |
| Petrol, 120 to 124g/km CO2 | £35,000 | 30% | £10,500 | £4,200 | £1,575 |
These are illustrations, not lease quotes. The petrol percentage is tied to the stated emissions band, not to every petrol car. The maximum appropriate percentage is 37% in 2026/27, including the diesel supplement where it applies.
By comparison, a £6,000 annual car allowance for someone already paying higher-rate tax produces £2,400 Income Tax and £120 employee National Insurance, plus £900 employer National Insurance. You still have to fund the car from the after-tax allowance, while a company-car comparison must include its own lease or purchase and running costs.
Is an electric company car different?
Yes. The zero-emission appropriate percentage is 4% in 2026/27 and 5% in 2027/28, then 7% in 2028/29 and 9% in 2029/30. Even after these rises, it is lower than the percentages applying to most higher-emission cars.
For Corporation Tax, a 100% first-year allowance is available for qualifying expenditure on a new, unused zero-emission car incurred by 31/03/2027. This is not an extra deduction for lease payments, and a second-hand electric car does not qualify for that first-year allowance. Timing and the exact car both matter.
If the company pays for a charging point at your home, it is only tax-free where the charger is used for a company car. If the company pays for a charger used for your own car, that is a taxable benefit. HMRC accepts that reimbursing the home electricity used to charge a company car is tax-free, provided the reimbursement covers only the company car's electricity, so keep evidence of how much was used. Electric charging is not treated like employer-provided petrol or diesel for private motoring.
What can the company claim for a company car or car allowance?
| Cost | Car allowance or director's own car | Company car |
|---|---|---|
| Allowance and employer NI | Normally deductible salary costs | Not applicable |
| Purchase | No company purchase deduction | Capital allowances; 100% FYA only for qualifying new zero-emission expenditure by 31/03/2027 |
| Other car purchases | Not applicable | Main-rate WDA is 14% for 50g/km or less and special-rate WDA 6% above 50g/km; the main rate is due to fall to 12% from 01/04/2027 (Corporation Tax) or 06/04/2027 (Income Tax), subject to legislation and timing rules |
| Lease | No company lease deduction | Rentals normally deductible, with a 15% restriction for cars above 50g/km |
| Business mileage | Approved mileage can be paid within the tax-free limits | Fuel/advisory-rate rules apply instead |
| Running costs | Director pays from after-tax income, apart from business mileage | Company may deduct business costs; private-use benefits still need reporting |
| VAT | Depends on the underlying personal arrangement | Purchase VAT normally blocked where there is private use; generally 50% of lease VAT where private use exists |
The VAT lines assume a VAT-registered, taxable business and common private-use circumstances. Pool cars, exclusive business use and other exceptions need a separate review.
Should I take a company car or car allowance?
Compare total annual cost, not tax alone. Include insurance, servicing, tyres, deposits, lease-end charges and personal mileage. Consider how long you will keep the car and whether salary sacrifice is more suitable than a conventional allowance.
Our company car tax guide for 2026/27 covers the benefit calculation in more detail. If the car forms part of your wider pay plan, read salary or dividends for 2026/27. Reporting also changes soon: Company cars enter mandatory payrolling from 06/04/2027, covered in our P11D and company cars guide.
The mistake we see most: Choosing on the monthly payment alone
A company car can look cheaper than a personal lease before the annual benefit tax is added. The opposite mistake is choosing an allowance without including employer National Insurance and your own after-tax running costs. Use the actual vehicle's list price, emissions, availability and mileage in the calculation.
Checklist: Before choosing a company car or car allowance
- Obtain the P11D list price, CO2 emissions and, for a hybrid, electric range.
- Estimate business and private mileage, excluding ordinary commuting.
- Calculate the director's benefit tax and the company's Class 1A National Insurance.
- Compare purchase, lease and allowance costs after Corporation Tax.
- For a new zero-emission purchase, check the 31/03/2027 first-year allowance deadline.
- Check VAT, fuel and home-charging treatment for the actual arrangement.
- Prepare payroll for mandatory company-car reporting from 06/04/2027.
Frequently asked questions
Is a car allowance tax-free for a director?
No. It is normally salary subject to PAYE Income Tax and National Insurance. Separate approved mileage payments for eligible business use of the director's own car can be tax-free within the approved limits.
Is a company electric car always better than an allowance?
No. Its low taxable benefit often helps, but the lease or purchase price, running costs and your mileage still determine the answer. Compare the full numbers for your situation.
Can I claim 55p a mile in a company car?
The approved mileage allowance rates for using your own vehicle do not apply in the same way to company cars. Employer reimbursement or repayment of company-car fuel normally uses the company-car fuel rules and advisory fuel rates instead.
Want the comparison run on your actual car?
We compare car choices alongside salary, dividends and other remuneration. See our tax planning service.