←

Payroll & Benefits

P11D and company cars from April 2027: What changes?

Patrick Booth, Clearcrest co-founder

P11D reporting changes fundamentally for company cars from 06/04/2027. Cars, car fuel, vans, van fuel and employer-provided medical benefits must be reported through payroll, with Income Tax and Class 1A National Insurance handled in real time. P11Ds for 2026/27 benefits remain due by 06/07/2027.

Most other benefits are due to follow from 06/04/2028. Employer-provided loans and accommodation will become eligible for voluntary payrolling from April 2027, but won't be mandatory under phase two.

★★★★★"What really stood out was their willingness to anticipate issues before they arose and provide practical solutions quickly, which made the whole experience far smoother and far less stressful."

Sam, owner of a management consultancy firm

More reviews from our clients

From Patrick, Clearcrest co-founder: "As accountants, we're always planning ahead for changes in legislation and reporting. When Making Tax Digital for Income Tax came in, we managed a smooth transition for all of our affected clients and made sure they felt supported throughout."

Which benefits move from P11D to payroll in April 2027?

HMRC has announced two phases:

Benefit 2027/28 From 2028/29
Company cars and car fuel Mandatory payroll reporting Mandatory payroll reporting
Vans and van fuel Mandatory payroll reporting Mandatory payroll reporting
Employer-provided medical benefits Mandatory payroll reporting Mandatory payroll reporting
Most other benefits Normal P11D rules, unless payrolled voluntarily Expected to be mandatory through payroll
Employer-provided loans Eligible for voluntary payrolling; otherwise P11D Voluntary; excluded from phase two
Living accommodation Eligible for voluntary payrolling; otherwise P11D Voluntary; excluded from phase two

For the mandated benefits, HMRC's measure says employers will no longer need to report them through P11D and P11D(b). That is different from saying every P11D disappears. The 2026/27 forms and any benefits outside the new mandate still need the appropriate treatment.

There is also an exception process for eligible globally mobile employees. It does not create a general right to opt out of payrolling a director's company car.

Will I still need a P11D for a company car?

Yes for a 2026/27 company-car benefit that has not been payrolled voluntarily. Submit P11D and P11D(b) by 06/07/2027 and pay Class 1A National Insurance electronically by 22/07/2027. The postal payment deadline is earlier, on 19/07/2027.

From 2027/28, the company's cars move into the new real-time process. Other benefits that remain outside mandatory payrolling will still need P11Ds, and any P11D(b) reporting that remains due must still be completed.

A beneficial loan can be one reason for a continuing P11D. If a director's loan is relevant, read our director's loan account guide, but do not assume it belongs in mandatory payroll in 2027/28.

What do I need to do before April 2027?

Start with a benefit-by-benefit list, then check that payroll can calculate and report each item correctly. HMRC reopened the voluntary payrolling registration service on 05/11/2026, with Class 1A functionality. Current GOV.UK guidance says cars, vans, fuel and medical insurance are handled directly through payroll software rather than the older voluntary registration route.

Work from your software provider's current setup instructions. Make sure the person running payroll knows how to:

  1. Obtain each car's P11D list price, CO2 figure, availability dates and private-use contribution details.
  2. Apply the appropriate percentage, including changes for part-year availability and replacement cars.
  3. Include the benefit value in real-time payroll information and collect Income Tax through PAYE.
  4. Report and account for Class 1A National Insurance through the new process.
  5. Explain the effect on each director's or employee's net pay and tax code.
  6. Identify benefits and employees for whom a P11D is still required.

For a zero-emission car, the 2027/28 appropriate percentage is 5%, not the 4% used in 2026/27. Our company car tax guide explains the basic calculation.

PAYE cannot deduct more than 50% of a person's cash pay in a pay period (the overriding limit), and that cash pay figure does not include the value of the payrolled benefit. A director on a small salary with a £10,000-plus car benefit will often not have all the tax collected through payroll. Any shortfall is carried forward to later pay periods in the same year if possible. What is still outstanding at the year end is collected through Self Assessment if the director already files it, or otherwise through HMRC's end-of-year reconciliation (P800), which may then be collected through a future tax code or a Simple Assessment. The company still needs a PAYE scheme running even if the director takes very little salary, because providing a taxable benefit requires one.

Does an electric company car change the P11D rules?

No. Electric cars still have a taxable benefit and are included in phase one. Their lower appropriate percentage reduces the benefit; it does not remove the reporting obligation.

Checklist dates therefore apply equally to petrol, diesel, hybrid and electric cars. A company moving from an annual P11D to payrolling will need accurate car data from the first 2027/28 pay run and updates whenever a car or its availability changes.

What is the penalty for late P11D filing?

For late P11D(b), HMRC can charge £100 for each month or part-month, for every group of 50 employees or fewer, for up to 12 months. Incorrect P11Ds can attract penalties, and late-paid Class 1A National Insurance can attract interest and late-payment charges.

Do not rely on the common shorthand that “late P11Ds cost £100 a month”. GOV.UK's employer reporting page identifies that particular fixed penalty with P11D(b). The necessary forms and any inaccuracies should be dealt with promptly.

The normal annual dates for years still using forms are P11D and P11D(b) by 06/07, and electronic Class 1A payment by 22/07. From April 2027, complying with the real-time requirements matters throughout the year rather than only at those annual dates.

Don't fall into this trap: Waiting for the final P11D before setting up payroll

The 2026/27 P11D deadline falls after mandatory payrolling has begun. A business that waits until July 2027 to think about the change will already have missed the setup needed for its first pay run. Keep the old-year forms and new-year payroll readiness as two separate workstreams.

Checklist: Preparing P11D and company cars for April 2027

  1. Complete any outstanding 2025/26 forms and resolve known errors.
  2. List every current benefit and who receives it.
  3. Record car list prices, emissions, availability dates and employee contributions.
  4. Confirm payroll software and processes support real-time benefit reporting and Class 1A National Insurance.
  5. Decide how non-mandated benefits will be reported. Employers who want to payroll other benefits voluntarily for 2027/28 must register by 05/04/2027. Existing registrations carry over automatically; to stop, deregister by the same date. From 2027/28, Class 1A National Insurance on voluntarily payrolled benefits is paid in-year through payroll rather than on a P11D(b).
  6. Test benefit calculations before the first pay run after 06/04/2027.
  7. Tell affected directors and employees how net pay will change.
  8. File remaining 2026/27 P11Ds and P11D(b) by 06/07/2027 and pay electronic Class 1A by 22/07/2027.
  9. Review phase-two guidance before 06/04/2028.

Frequently asked questions

Does P11D end completely in April 2027?

No. Company cars, fuel, vans and employer-provided medical benefits move into mandatory payroll reporting, but 2026/27 forms are still due and other benefits can remain on P11Ds. Employer-provided loans and accommodation become eligible for voluntary payrolling from April 2027, but will not be mandatory under phase two. The wider second phase begins in April 2028.

Do directors have to payroll company cars themselves?

The employer performs the payroll reporting and normally operates PAYE through its payroll arrangements. An accountant or payroll bureau can help, but the company needs accurate benefit data and a working process in place.

Is private medical insurance included from April 2027?

Yes, employer-provided medical benefits are in phase one. Confirm the specific policy and recipient details so the correct taxable value is reported.

Getting benefits and payroll ready for 2027?

We can help review the benefits your company provides and how they fit your accounting and payroll work. See what our service includes, or compare the car itself in our company car or car allowance guide.

Prefer to talk?

Get advice tailored to your business.

A relaxed discovery call, no obligation, no jargon.

Book a discovery call